The Jewish Week is always here for you.
We need your support now.
Your contribution will help us bring you vital news
and frequent updates about the impact of COVID-19.
A Soldier’s Duty

A Soldier’s Duty

“Hero Or Murderer?” (Editorial, April 8) discussed the issue of the soldier who shot a
terrorist in the head after the terrorist was already lying prone on the ground. The
Editorial gives the impression that “decades of terror attacks… have
taken their toll on a society”… (and) …on society’s capacity for
compassion. Unfortunately, we in America look at this case from our eyes, not
from that of a soldier who is tasked to maintain security. 

I returned recently from a trip to Israel where my granddaughter and I
took a security course in which soldiers explained how they are taught to
respond to an attack. It was explained to us that
if a soldier is in a predicament where he has subdued one suspect but there
may be other terrorists present and the situation is still not secure, it may
be necessary to eliminate the subdued suspect so the soldier can secure the situation and prevent further civilian casualties.

I am not suggesting that we condone unnecessary violence, and neither is the
IDF. However, an attack such as this one needs to be examined in the context of
Israeli needs and not American sensibilities. It may have been a mistake by
this soldier, but in the context of Israeli society, it is far better that a
terrorist is killed than an innocent civilian. This does not at all
reflect on Israel’s capacity for compassion; rather it is about the need to deal
with the everyday reality of terror. Israel is a very compassionate society, but its focus is more toward the innocent victims of terror than to the
terrorists, and that is morally correct.


read more: